Top 10 Lead Generation Software for Insurance Agents

LeadSend delivers consistent, high-quality leads effortlessly at $499/month!
Book a Demo
By LeadSend
By LeadSend
May 14, 2024
Top 10 Lead Generation Software for Insurance Agents

Key Takeaways

  • Lead generation software can help insurance agents attract more qualified leads and automate the prospecting process.
  • With multiple insurance lead generation tools available, choose one that fits your business needs, scales with your organization, and supports high-volume lead management.
  • LeadSend helps you reach over 22,000 new decision-makers each month, ensuring a consistent lead flow.

Tired of spending endless hours chasing after leads that never seem to pan out? You're not alone, if you're an insurance agent, hustling day in and day out to find new clients.

Attracting new clients is crucial. However, prospecting can be time-consuming and frustrating. That's where insurance lead generation software comes in. 

These powerful tools can help you identify, target, and connect with potential customers, streamlining your sales process.

This blog explores the top 10 insurance lead generation software options, along with valuable tips to help you choose the right one for your agency.

Best 10 Insurance Lead Generation Software for Agents/Agencies

Software Pricing Trusted Customers Reviews Key Features
LeadSend Starts at $499/month Beacon, Cornerstone companies, BIG broker insurance company 4.9/5 AI-powered lead identification, personalized outreach, automated follow-ups, CRM integration, data-driven insights, quick setup, flexible targeting
HubSpot Starts at $45/month Eventbrite, DoorDash, Canadian Red Cross 4.5/5 Automated email sequences, landing pages, lead activity insights, marketing performance tracking
Salesforce Essentials Starts at $25/month PepeJeans London, Genpact, Flame University 4.5/5 Integration with Salesforce CRM, centralized customer data management, scalable for growing agencies
EngageBay Starts at $14.99/month Neil Patel, Tech Crunch, jeffbullas 4.6/5 All-in-one marketing, sales, and customer service platform, centralized communication channels
Freshsales Starts at $15/month Bridgestone, TaylorMade, Blue Nile 4.5/5 Lead scoring, AI-powered chatbots, lead capture forms, lead routing, task automation
NetHunt CRM Starts at $35/month Powerglide, 100systems, OneThreeOneFour 4.6/5 Customizable fields and workflows, seamless integration with Gmail and Google Workspace, drag-and-drop sales pipeline
Constant Contact Starts at $20/month Flavorman, Tea’s Me Cafe, Pet Wants Newton 4/5 User-friendly email marketing campaigns, drag-and-drop functionality, pre-designed templates, budget-friendly for small agencies
Keap (Infusionsoft) Contact for quote Avalon Pharmacy, Bed and Breakfast Coach, Lifeonaire 4.2/5 Marketing automation, social media posting, lead nurturing campaigns, complex sales funnels
AgencyBloc Contact for quote Apollo Insurance Group, Golden Light Insurance, Seniority Benefit Group 4.2/5 Designed for insurance industry, integrated CRM, quoting and policy management tools, streamlined workflows
AgentCubed Contact for quote Scan, Highmark, National General Insurance 2.3/5 CRM system accessible from anywhere, task automation, efficient policy management

1. LeadSend

Imagine you're an insurance agent, tired of endless cold calls. What if you could find qualified leads already interested in your offer?

LeadSend can be your secret weapon. Forget expensive Facebook Ads or dialing random numbers. Here's how it works:

  • Sign up for a plan: Choose a plan that fits your budget, like the $499 per month option.
  • Target your audience: Tell LeadSend who you want to reach, like "local businesses needing insurance."
  • Let LeadSend do the magic: The platform finds potential clients and helps you craft personalized emails.
  • Start closing deals: Within days, you could get responses and secure new clients, all without the cold calling hassle!

Don't just take our word for it: LeadSend clients report getting an average of 22,000 new decision-makers interested in their services every month!

Look what founders and VP say about LeadSend here: 

Pricing: Starts at $499/month

Trusted customers: Beacon, Cornerstone companies, BIG broke insurance company 

Reviews: 4.9/5 

2. HubSpot

HubSpot can become your lead nurturing hub! 

Create automated email sequences that educate and engage potential clients, guiding them through the sales funnel with targeted content and personalized offers. Landing pages capture leads by providing valuable resources in exchange for contact information.

Next, gain valuable insights into lead activity and marketing performance. Track metrics like website traffic, email open rates, lead conversion rates, and identify areas for improvement in your marketing strategy.

Pricing: Free trial for a month and then starts at $45/month.

Trusted customers: Eventbrite, DoorDash, Canadian Red Cross

Reviews: 4.5/5 (G2)

3. Salesforce Essentials

Salesforce Essentials is designed to grow with your agency. As your team expands and your needs evolve, the platform can easily adapt to accommodate additional users and features.

Integrates seamlessly with the robust Salesforce CRM platform, allowing you to manage all your customer data (including leads, contacts, and opportunities) in one centralized location. This fosters a more streamlined workflow and improves data visibility.

Pricing: Start for free. Later $25/month.

Trusted customers: PepeJeans London, Genpact, Flame University

Reviews: 4.5/5 (G2)

4. EngageBay

Manage your marketing, sales, and customer service activities within a single platform, eliminating the need for multiple tools and subscriptions. This simplifies your workflow and reduces overall costs.

Make and receive phone calls directly within the EngageBay platform. This eliminates the need to switch between different applications and keeps all communication channels centralized.

Pricing: Free plan available, paid plans start at $14.99/month.

Trusted customers: Neil Patel, Tech Crunch, jeffbullas

Reviews: 4.6/5 (G2)

5. Freshsales

With Freshsales, you assign scores to leads based on their level of engagement and interest. This helps you prioritize leads that are most likely to convert and allocate your time effectively. Freshsales also provides tools to manage leads efficiently, including lead capture forms, lead routing, and task automation.

Leverage the power of artificial intelligence with features like chatbots that can engage with website visitors, qualify leads, and schedule appointments. This frees up your time for more complex tasks.

Pricing: Starts at $15/month.

Trusted customers: Bridgestone, TaylorMade, Blue Nile

Reviews: 4.5/5 (G2)

6. NetHunt CRM

NetHunt CRM allows you to customize fields, pipelines, and workflows to specifically meet the needs of your insurance agency. This ensures the platform aligns with your unique insurance specialties and processes.

Integrate NetHunt CRM seamlessly with Gmail and other Google Workspace applications (like Docs and Sheets). This streamlines your workflow by allowing you to access and manage client information directly from the tools you already use.

Gain a clear visual representation of your sales pipeline with NetHunt CRM's drag-and-drop interface. This allows you to easily track the progress of leads, identify bottlenecks, and optimize your sales process.

Pricing: Starts at $35/month.

Trusted customers: Powerglide, 100systems, OneThreeOneFour

Reviews: 4.6/5 (G2)

7. Constant Contact

Create visually appealing and engaging email marketing campaigns with Constant Contact's user-friendly interface. Drag-and-drop functionality and pre-designed templates make it easy to get started, even for those with limited design experience.

A budget-friendly option for agencies starting out in lead generation. Constant Contact offers tiered pricing plans that scale with your needs, making it a good choice for agencies with limited marketing budgets.

Pricing: Starts at $20/month.

Trusted customers: Flavorman, Tea’s Me Cafe, Pet Wants Newton

Reviews: 4/5 (G2) 

8. Keap (formerly Infusionsoft)

Automate repetitive marketing tasks like email sequences, social media posting, and lead nurturing campaigns. Keap frees up your time to focus on building relationships and closing deals.

Create and manage complex sales funnels with Keap. This allows you to design a multi-step process for nurturing leads and converting them into paying clients.

Pricing: Contact Keap for a quote after 14 14-day free trial.

Trusted customers: Avalon Pharmacy, Bed and Breakfast Coach, Lifeonaire

Reviews: 4.2/5 (G2)

9. AgencyBloc

Designed specifically for the insurance industry, AgencyBloc streamlines workflows by offering features tailored to insurance agents. This includes functionalities for quoting, policy management, and client communication, all within one platform.

Eliminate the need for multiple software solutions with AgencyBloc's integrated CRM, quoting, and policy management tools. This reduces data silos and improves overall efficiency.

Pricing: Contact AgencyBloc for a quote.

Trusted customers: Apollo Insurance Group, Golden Light Insurance, Seniority Benefit Group

Reviews: 4.2/5 (G2)

10. AgentCubed

Access your agency's data and manage your CRM system from anywhere with an internet connection. This allows for greater flexibility and collaboration among team members.

Automate repetitive tasks like sending policy renewal reminders, generating reports, and following up with leads. This frees up your time to focus on higher-value activities.

Simplify policy management processes with AgentCubed. Manage new applications, renewals, and cancellations efficiently

Pricing: Contact AgentCubed for a quote and demo.

Trusted customers: Scan, Highmark, National General Insurance 

Reviews: 2.3/5 (G2)

How to choose the best insurance lead generation software for your agency?

Finding new clients can be a challenge for any insurance agency. Lead generation software can help by attracting potential customers who are interested in the kind of insurance you offer. But with so many options, choosing the right software can feel overwhelming. Here are some key things to consider:

1. Budget and Team Size:

Imagine software like a toolbox. A smaller agency might need a basic toolbox with a few essential tools. But a larger agency might need a bigger toolbox with more features for everyone on the team. Consider your budget and team size when choosing software.

2. Who Are You Helping?

Do you specialize in auto insurance for young drivers, or perhaps life insurance for families? Knowing your target market is important. Choose software that allows you to reach the specific people who need your insurance expertise.

3. Picking the Right Features:

Think about the features that would make your job easier. Do you need forms for people to easily request quotes? Maybe email tools to stay connected with potential clients? Consider features like lead capture forms, email marketing, and even integrations with other software you use.

4. Keeping it Simple:

The best software is easy to use, even for people who aren't very tech-savvy. Look for software with a clear interface and helpful instructions. Some software even offers training or support to get you started.

By considering these factors, you can choose insurance lead generation software that fits your agency's needs and helps you find the right clients. Remember, the right software can save you time and effort, and ultimately help your agency grow!

5 effective lead generation tips for insurance agents

While software can be a great help, there are many other ways to attract new clients to your insurance agency. Here are 5 effective lead generation tips you can try:

1. Using Content Marketing:

Imagine you have a library filled with helpful resources all about insurance. That's what content marketing is like! Create informative blog posts, videos, or even social media posts that educate people about different types of insurance and the questions they might have. The more people see you as a reliable source of information, the more likely they are to trust you with their insurance needs.

2. Making Connections and Sharing Knowledge:

Social media platforms like LinkedIn and Facebook are like giant online communities. Use them to connect with potential clients, answer their questions, and share interesting information about insurance. By establishing yourself as a thought leader, you'll be at the top of people's minds when they need insurance.

3. Building Relationships That Lead to Success:

Think of networking as attending a party where everyone is there to help each other. Attend industry events, connect with other professionals like realtors or financial advisors, and build relationships. They might recommend your services to their clients, bringing new business your way.

4. Attracting Clients Like a Magnet:

Your website is your online storefront. Make sure it's easy to navigate and find information about the insurance products you offer. Optimizing your website for search engines can also help people looking for insurance find you online.

5. Reaching the Right People at the Right Time:

Imagine placing an ad for car insurance right next to an article about car safety tips. That's the power of targeted online advertising! Consider using pay-per-click (PPC) advertising to reach people who are already searching for insurance products online. This can be a great way to connect with potential clients who are ready to buy.

By trying these simple lead generation tips, you can attract more potential clients to your insurance agency and grow your business!


What is a lead generator in insurance?

Think of it as a magnet for potential clients actively searching for coverage. Lead generation tools identify and connect these hot leads to you, a superstar agent ready to solve their insurance woes. Imagine someone, stressed about rising auto insurance costs, is filling out an online quote form. A lead generator matches them with your agency, putting you in the driver's seat to convert them into a happy, long-term client.

How do I get more leads for insurance agency?

This blog post is your roadmap to lead gen gold! We've covered a toolbox of tactics, from using lead generation software like [insert popular lead gen software example] to crafting informative blog posts (think "Top 5 Myths About Home Insurance Debunked!"). Remember, social media is your friend – connect with local groups and showcase your expertise. Networking events are a great way to build relationships, and optimizing your website for search engines ensures potential clients can find you easily. Paid advertising (PPC) can also be a game-changer, putting your agency at the forefront of online searches.

What is the cost of insurance lead generation software?

The price varies depending on features and your agency's size. Some providers offer monthly subscriptions, while others charge per lead. The key is to find a solution that fits your budget and goals. Think of it as an investment – the return can be substantial in terms of new clients and boosted revenue.

Bonus Tip: Don't underestimate the power of a compelling follow-up strategy. Respond promptly to leads, showcase your knowledge, and highlight how your services can meet their specific needs. By providing exceptional customer service from the get-go, you'll be well on your way to closing more deals and building lasting client relationships.


Ditch Fancy Agencies, Overpriced Ads & Get Started With

Book a Demo